Hello dear
Welcome To Brooklyn Pie Co.
At Brooklyn Pie Co., located in the heart of Austin, the passion for authentic pizza shines through. Inspired by classic New York styles, their pies feature perfect crusts and vibrant toppings that transport you to the streets of Brooklyn. Offering a range of options, including savory calzones and fresh salads, they cater to every palate, including vegetarians. The cozy atmosphere welcomes families and groups alike, while the availability of delivery and takeout ensures you can savor their delicious offerings anytime. With glowing reviews highlighting the quality and taste of the pizza, Brooklyn Pie Co. is where flavor and tradition unite for a truly delightful experience.
About
Brooklyn Pie Co.
Welcome to Brooklyn Pie Co., a delightful addition to the Austin pizza scene, nestled at 9500 S I-35 Frontage Rd. This vibrant eatery has captured the hearts of both locals and visitors with its dedication to crafting authentic New York-style pizza that transports you straight to the bustling streets of Brooklyn. Whether you're a lifelong pizza lover or simply in search of a quick, satisfying meal, Brooklyn Pie Co. promises to deliver a memorable dining experience.
At Brooklyn Pie Co., the focus is on quality. Their pizzas boast a perfectly thick yet airy crust, offering that classic New York bite that so many seek. Customers rave about the savory pies—especially the Build Your Own Cheese Pizza, available for just $15.00. The sauce is a standout feature, made without overpowering garlic, letting the flavors of fresh tomatoes shine through. One satisfied customer, Linda S., even remarked how the pizza reminded her of Italy, citing the excellent taste and texture. It’s these authentic touches that keep patrons coming back.
If you’re in the mood for something different, check out their selection of Paninis and Subs. A popular choice is the Grilled Chicken Panini, which combines mozzarella, roasted red peppers, onions, grilled chicken, and pesto for just $13.00. Alternatively, the Italian Sub—complete with provolone, ham, salami, pepperoni, and Italian vinaigrette—offers a hearty experience for those craving something classic yet fulfilling.
- Pizzas: High-quality, New York-style with a range of customizable toppings.
- Paninis and Subs: Flavorful options that cater to diverse palates.
- Sides: Kettle Chips for just $3.50, perfect for nibbling.
- Customer Experience: Mostly positive feedback with mentions of great delivery and in-store dining experiences.
While the seating is limited, many guests, like Julia C., have turned to delivery options via Uber Eats and Door Dash, maintaining the satisfaction of hot, crispy pizzas at home. Minor critiques about the timing and additional costs have not deterred fans; they have discovered that the quality of pizza more than compensates for these small inconveniences.
In a city sprawling with various dining options, Brooklyn Pie Co. stands out with its commitment to authentic flavors and welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're reminiscing about a slice from New York City or just seeking a fantastic meal, this pizzeria invites you to indulge in the true essence of pizza perfection. With the phone number (512) 284-7780 on hand for inquiries and orders, it’s time to treat yourself to a pie that truly satisfies.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ As Italian, my pizza standards are pretty high. I have to admit that this pizza is very good! Some friends and I ordered pizza to spend the evening together and I was surprised right away! The dough was perfectly thick, and the taste was just like the one you can eat in Italy. The tomato sauce was excellent and I personally love that it wasn't mixed with garlic (which I've seen done in other places) And the cheese was not too greasy. Overall I really enjoyed it and I definitely recommend it! ”
“ Really good pizza but the toppings price on uber eats is kind of out of control. This has been my go to pizza place since i moved to south Austin and dont feel like going to homeslice. ”
“ Love the giant slice (and I'm from a few miles across the GW Bridge from Manhattan)! Negatives - Very little seating, opens an hour later on weekends (noon) so forget about picking up pizza before the NFL games start, and no free water. ”
“ Didn't feel like ordering our normal dominoes, and went against the 3-star reviews on this joint. So glad I did! We've actually ordered by Uber Eats and Door Dash. The first time, order was perfect. Second time, they added the wrong sauce to one of our pies. But the pizzas arrived hot, crispy, and great! I want to try eating in-store sometime, but so far we've been very happy with our deliveries. Similar to the pizzas I had in NYC. ”
“ What a good pie... specifically a Classic New York Pizza Pie, small size (don't tease me, stuff is expensive enough nowadays!). This pizza was very good and brought back memories of the last great New York style pizza I had (which was Davinci's in Charlotte, NC). I'm not from New York and I may not know what authentic is-- but I know what I like, and this was delicious! Even the crust was nice and soft and wonderful, just like I like it. I could snack on just the crust! They forgot my request (online ordering w/Grubhub) for no sausage-- but I swear that this sausage wasn't bad at all. Very mild and nice tasting slices of sausage. This was one time that I didn't mind a mistake on my food. Based on this first experience, I will definitely be getting more Brooklyn Pie Co's pizza! It's not easy finding pizza I like here in Austin. ”
“ Our pager died while we were watering so that was a bummer but incredibly helpful and nice staff. Got the fried ravioli and churro cheesecake. Fried ravioli was AMAZING. Six pieces with marinara, so delicious! Churro cheesecake was also amazing. Good size and delicious. ”
